> Home...

COMMITTEE FOR GREEN FOOTHILLS
> Learn about our projects...> Help save open space!> The latest news...> Support our work...> Find out about us...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CGF In The News

 

News
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Sign up for Email Updates
CGF In the News
Press Inquiries
Past Articles
Calendar

 

 

Milpitas Post
August 01, 2002
 
Subdivision proposed  on hillside ranch

By Jay Peeples

 The County of Santa Clara will hold a community  meeting next week to discuss the impending environmental review of a 17-lot  residential development in the foothills east of Milpitas.

During the Aug. 6 meeting, to be held at the Milpitas  Police Department Community Room, 1275 N. Milpitas Blvd., from 7 to 9  p.m., the county is asking for comments from the community related to  the upcoming environmental impact review of The Vintage Estates Cluster  Subdivision. It proposes 17 residential lots, from two to four acres each,  clustered near the intersection of Felter and Marsh roads, and a 517-acre  parcel to be designated as open space. The development is planned on the  wildlife-rich Patrick family ranch, commonly known as the JMP Ranch.

County Associate Planner Derek Farmer said the meeting  will allow residents to specify what they would like to see addressed  in the environmental review.

"We want to take public input," Farmer  said.

According to Farmer, the project is proposed by Santa  Clara-based Citation Homes, which did not return calls for comment. The  land for the proposed development - one of the largest contiguous private  holdings in an area dominated by vast San Francisco Water Department acreage  - is still owned by the Patrick family, he said.

Farmer said the development is called a "cluster  subdivision," which means lots are built in a cluster, leaving most  of the land for open space. Farmer said the developer will only be allowed  to build residential units on 10 percent of the total land, while the  remaining 90 percent must be designated as permanent open space.

"The main concern right now is the visual impacts,"  Farmer said, explaining that a majority of the ranch-style homes will  be built on ridgelands.

Hillside preservation and wildlife groups have already  spoken out against the development. The Committee for Green Foothills  and the Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society have filed joint letters to  the Santa Clara County Planning Commission. That body OK'd the conformity  of the development with county regulations, despite opposition.

"This is a divergence from hillside zoning because  the homes are predominately on the ridges, more like an octopus layout.  The dedicated open space is separated and weaves in between homes in long,  skinny fingers," said Denice Dade, the Committee for Green Foothills'  Santa Clara County legislative advocate. "That's why we believe this  is not an appropriate design for the eastern foothills."

Dade said the project will be visible from Felter  Road, northern Milpitas and downtown San Jose.

In letters to the county planners and the planning  commission, the Committee for Green Foothills and the Santa Clara Valley  Audubon Society argue that the proposal is different than any other cluster  subdivision proposal the county has historically approved. The groups  said the site design is inconsistent with the county's general plan, which  states "roads, building sites, structures and other facilities shall  not be allowed to create major, lasting visible scars on the landscape."  Further, "those portions of land permanently preserved as open space  shall be configured as large, contiguous and usable areas."

The series of letters from the environmental groups  also claim the development of the project would be unfair to Milpitas  residents, who passed an urban growth boundary in 1998. The main purposes  of Measure Z were to prevent annexation of county land to the city, and  to prohibit city services from being extended to hillside developments.

Farmer said the proposed development would not be  connected to city services, and each home would likely have a septic tank  and well.

Citizens Committee for Measure Z Chair Maria Archuleta-Lemery,  who fought vehemently to keep the western face open in 1998, said she  is not opposed to this development.

"I think the Patricks are entitled to develop  some of that property," she said. "How could anyone object to  17 homes on 500-plus acres?"

Farmer said the environmental review process should  last about six months, and a draft impact report should be released by  October or November. The project will return to the county planning commission  and, ultimately, face the county Board of Supervisors. The project is  expected to be heard by the board early next year, Farmer said.


Page last updated August 9, 2002 .

 

 

Copyright 2001 Committee for Green Foothills